Comparing 8GB RAM to 16GB: Apple's Latest Claim.

 

Apple's marketing VP, Bob Berer, claims that the M3 MacBook Pro with only 8GB of RAM can match PCs with 16GB. This is an intriguing statement that we will dive deep into and explore. Let's see if Apple's claim holds up.

What Makes the M3 Chip Special?

The M3 chip in the MacBook Pro blends the CPU, GPU, and RAM together, which Apple argues makes it ultra fast and efficient. But can this unique design really make 8GB of RAM perform as well as 16GB? Let's take a closer look.

Performance Gap

In Apple's own tests, the new MacBook Pro excels at everyday tasks. However, when pushed with demanding apps like video editing tools, the 8GB version tends to fall behind its 16GB counterpart. This clearly indicates a performance gap between the two models.

Memory Swapping

Another key feature of Apple's design is memory swapping, where the Mac uses part of its SSD as extra RAM. While SSDs are fast, they are not as quick as RAM. Additionally, using SSDs in this manner may shorten their lifespan. This raises concerns about memory management and potential impacts on performance.

Choosing the Right RAM

For basic tasks, 8GB of RAM should be sufficient. However, for more intense workloads like video editing or 3D design, it is recommended to opt for the 16GB model. As apps become more demanding, having additional RAM becomes crucial. Upgrading a Mac is no longer a simple task, so making the right choice upfront is important.

Comparing RAM Usage

A unique setup involving a Mackintosh running both macOS and Windows allows for a direct comparison of RAM usage across the same hardware. The RAM usage appears to be similar on both operating systems, even for tasks like web browsing.

The Importance of RAM for Third-Party Apps

Third-party apps, such as After Effects, require a significant amount of RAM for large projects. Without enough RAM, these projects cannot even be opened. This highlights the real difference that additional RAM can make in certain scenarios.

Apple's Strategy

It seems that Apple's claim about 8GB of RAM being as good as 16GB is a strategy to make the 8GB MacBook Pro seem more appealing despite its higher price. In a world where 8GB may feel limited on a premium laptop, the $200 jump to 16GB RAM becomes a more attractive option.

Apple has a history of making bold claims, such as with the butterfly keyboards, which ultimately faced numerous problems. It is not uncommon for tech companies to hype up their products. However, with the M3 MacBook Pro, we are seeing a noticeable performance difference that is hard to ignore.

Final Thoughts

The M3 chip in the MacBook Pro is undoubtedly a step forward. However, the claim that 8GB of RAM can compete with 16GB is still up for debate. For light tasks, the 8GB model should suffice. But for anything more demanding, opting for the 16GB or higher is a smarter choice. In personal experience, using 32GB of RAM on a MacBook Pro has provided smooth performance for high-demanding workloads. Thus, RAM remains a critical factor.

How much ram should you get in 2023?